Compromise Is Not What You Think It Is—And It Doesn’t Have to Hurt
A framework for mutually beneficial deal making
Why We Get Compromise Wrong
A lot of us have been taught that compromise is mutual loss. Too often we resent and avoid anything that even looks like compromise because to many it means mutual loss, or mutual deprivation. You give something up, I give something up, and if we both walk away feeling slightly deprived, we call it fair.
That’s not compromise. That’s just a direct path to resentment.
Real compromise doesn’t have to be about suffering. It’s not about one person swallowing discomfort while the other gets their way. It’s about finding a solution that actually works for both people—a solution that strengthens the relationship rather than weakens it. When compromise feels like suffering, that’s a sign something is off. Not necessarily with the relationship, but with the way negotiation is happening.
We often think of compromise as transactional—like a contract where both parties give something up begrudgingly. But real, sustainable Compromise can be a creative act—it’s about problem-solving, collaboration, and designing solutions that genuinely work for both people rather than just splitting the difference. It’s about building something that meets both people’s needs rather than diminishing both people’s happiness. If compromise consistently feels like a loss, it’s a sign that something is being overlooked: the why behind the ask.
The Problem with Focusing on Behavior Alone
Let’s say one person in a relationship wants daily communication, and the other doesn’t. The conversation usually plays out like this:
Person A: I need you to text me every day.
Person B: That feels forced to me.
Person A: Well, I feel unloved if you don’t.
Now, Person B is sending dutiful texts, and Person A is monitoring frequency like a scorecard. But does either person feel seen? Probably not.
That’s because the request (daily texting) isn’t the need. It’s just one possible strategy to meet a deeper need. So what’s the real need here?
Do you feel unimportant or unconsidered when check-ins are inconsistent?
Does the lack of communication make you anxious, questioning the security of the relationship?
Do you start wondering if your needs actually matter, or if you’re just an afterthought?
Does it stir up a sense of disconnection, like the emotional gap between you is widening?
Do you find yourself frustrated because it feels like you’re always the one holding the connection together?
These aren’t just petty annoyances. They’re signals. And when we fixate on specific behaviors instead of the underlying feelings, we end up self-regulating through someone else's actions rather than addressing our own emotional needs. This can quietly turn the other person into an object—someone we rely on to manage our inner world, rather than a partner we’re in relationship with. The more we externalize regulation by attempting to shift behavior instead of speaking to our needs, the less we learn to meet our own emotional landscape with care, and the more we risk making the other person responsible for emotions they can’t fully control. But when we focus on the feeling rather than the behavior, we open up far more paths to solutions—ones that allow for connection rather than control.
Rethinking Compromise: A Framework for Finding Solutions That Work
Instead of forcing concessions, let’s shift from rigid expectations to meaningful connection. Here’s how:
1. Clarify the Emotional Need
Instead of saying "I need daily texts," ask yourself:
What does consistent communication give me emotionally?
When I don’t receive it, what emotions arise?
What is the underlying need here—reassurance, closeness, structure, engagement?
By identifying the deeper emotional need, you stop treating behaviors as rigid obligations and start seeing them as opportunities for connection.
2. Open Up Possibilities
Once you identify the real need, there are countless ways to meet it beyond just one behavior. Some alternatives:
A voice memo or short check-in at the same time each day
Sharing an article, song, or meme to spark conversation later
Playing an ongoing game together that keeps communication light and fun
Establishing a reliable rhythm for deeper conversations, like a weekly call
Setting an expectation of “update texts” at key moments rather than daily check-ins
The key is flexibility—finding ways to connect that feel natural rather than obligatory.
3. Prioritize Authenticity Over Obligation
For compromise to work, it has to feel good for both people. Otherwise, resentment builds. Ask yourself:
Does this solution feel sustainable and natural?
Am I showing up in a way that feels true to me, rather than just checking a box?
Are we both engaging in a way that fosters genuine care and connection?
A healthy compromise isn’t about grit-your-teeth endurance; it’s about co-creating a dynamic that feels right for both of you.
Dr. Stan Tatkin, founder of the PACT Institute, puts it simply:
“In secure-functioning relationships, you don’t try to win. You try to serve the relationship.”
Compromise isn’t about you vs. me—it’s about us. The real question isn’t just what do I need? or what do you need? but what strengthens the whole?
4. Compromise as a Bargain, Not a Sacrifice
Tatkin also makes a crucial distinction: effective compromise is a bargain, not a sacrifice.
In the old model:
❌ I give something up.
❌ I endure discomfort.
❌ I comply resentfully.
In a secure-functioning model:
✅ I offer something up to get something meaningful back.
✅ I find a way to meet both our needs in a way that strengthens us.
✅ I negotiate with care, not grudgingly “giving in.”
Because at the end of the day, the goal isn’t just to keep the peace—it’s to build something worth keeping.
The Takeaway: Compromise Should Feel Like Collaboration
Healthy compromise doesn’t mean taking turns being unhappy. It means working together to find creative, sustainable ways to meet each other’s needs without resentment.
A final gut-check question:
👉 Does this compromise make our relationship feel stronger and more connected? If yes, you’re on the right track. If not, keep experimenting. Because the best relationships aren’t about endurance—they’re about designing something that works for both of you.
Support My Sabbatical & the Completion of My Book
If my writing has resonated with you, if you believe in the work I’m doing, or if you simply want to help me finish this book while navigating a life-changing health transition, I’d deeply appreciate your support. I’ve reactivated my GoFundMe to take a full sabbatical, leave Berlin for a quieter space in nature, and focus on completing this book through the summer and autumn. Every contribution, big or small, makes a difference—and sharing helps too.
Thank you for being here. It truly means the world.